Reflections on the MAGI: the Blindness of Biblical Literacy Alone

First posted January 2, 2020:

It’s my honor to introduce my current “Guest Branch,” our Pastor of Discipleship, Paul Pyle. Paul’s claim to fame in our household is that he was a favorite Bible teacher of our son Jeremy and daughter-in-law Cortney at Dayton Christian High School “back in the day.”

John and I respect Paul and benefit so much by his ministry, and so I wanted to share one of the selections from his blog called “Discipleship Weekly.” In December 2019, Paul posted the following piece about my heroes, the Magi. I absolutely love Paul’s insights and application to our own lives today as Bible knowing and believing Christians.

Thank you, Pastor Paul, for permission to again share this thought-provoking piece.

The Blindness of Biblical Literacy Alone
by Paul Pyle

I’ve been thinking about the wise men recently. I can’t help but notice how different those Gentile seekers were from Israel’s wise men, the experts in the Law whom Herod consulted.

You remember the story. Wise men ride into Jerusalem and create a stir.

Surely their appearance alone would have been noteworthy. We don’t know how many of them there were, only that they were plural. There could have been a dozen, or more. And surely they would have had an armed escort for the long journey from the east. And many beasts of burden carrying supplies. And many attendants and servants. It must have been an impressive sight, the great caravan of these visitors riding into Jerusalem.

But it was their quest that most troubled Herod, the so-called “king” of the Jews. Those exotic visitors had the temerity to ask, “Where is he who is born king of the Jews, for we have come to worship him.”

We won’t spend time on Herod’s paranoia, which led him eventually to slaughter all the male children two years and younger throughout the village of Bethlehem and the surrounding area.

No, as tragic as that atrocity was, there was another tragedy: the blindness of Israel’s wise men.

These were men who knew the Scripture. When Herod asked them where the Messiah would be born, they didn’t speculate about which of the great families of Jerusalem might produce such a man. No, they knew that the tiny, unimpressive village of Bethlehem, some five miles away, would be the birthplace of the Messiah.

How did they know such a thing? God’s prophet, Micah, had predicted as much eight centuries earlier. Matthew’s gospel records the conversation between Herod and Israel’s wise men:

…assembling all the chief priests and scribes of the people, [Herod] inquired of them where the Christ was to be born. They told him, “In Bethlehem of Judea, for so it is written by the prophet:
“‘And you, O Bethlehem, in the land of Judah,
    are by no means least among the rulers of Judah;
for from you shall come a ruler
    who will shepherd my people Israel.’” Matthew 2:4-6, ESV

It’s what happens next that is so disturbing. Along with all of Jerusalem, Israel’s wise men knew why the visitors from the east had come. The visitors were looking for the newly born king of the Jews. It’s clear that the wise men of Israel knew where that king would be born.

So what did they do next? Nothing. The wise men of Israel contribute nothing more to the Christmas story beyond playing the role of informants, telling the murderously paranoid Herod where he could find the baby.

The Gentile seekers were led to Jerusalem by a celestial phenomenon, the star. They were not experts in the Scriptures, but they were driven to learn more about what God was doing in their day. And they undertook an arduous journey that probably took months to find the answer to their question.

Israel’s wise men knew the Scripture, yet they were not motivated to find out for themselves what God had done. They weren’t motivated enough to travel five miles to Bethlehem to see for themselves.

I love the Scripture, I’ve known the Scripture since I was a small boy. But I understand that Bible knowledge alone cannot generate spiritual vitality.

We must be careful of a category error here: All people who possess spiritual vitality have a great love and hunger for God’s Word. It is because they love God, because God’s Spirit is working in their heart and life that they are so driven to know the Scriptures. They are driven not just by curiosity but by spiritual hunger to hear from God.

But the opposite is not true: Not all people who know the Bible possess spiritual vitality. In fact, biblical literacy alone can be toxic. Jesus’s most implacable enemies were experts in the Scriptures. In fact, it was that same body of wise men – Israel’s Sanhedrin – who finally persuaded a reluctant Roman governor Pilate to have Jesus slain. 

The failure of Israel’s wise men and the great hunger of the Gentile seekers provide an instructive contrast between the barrenness of mere knowledge and the fruitfulness of genuine spiritual hunger.

God spare me from the barrenness of merely knowing His Word.  
Persevere,
Paul Pyle
Discipleship Pastor

You can now view Discipleship Weekly on our website! Read and share this week's encouragement with friends and family.